We opened our bakery in the heart of the Surrey village of Milford 8 years ago in 2012, following the success of our stall on Guildford's North Street Market, which 12 years on is still a big part of our business. We are there come rain or shine every Friday and Saturday, and in our new location at the bottom of the market, 2nd stall, next to the Artisan Bread Stall.

Our sister company Eliza's Tea Room is just around the corner at Secretts Farm Shop where you can enjoy a slice of our Coffee & Walnut Cake, Victoria Sponge or our delicious Great Taste 2* Award winning gluten free Almond Bar, with an excellent cup of coffee.

Website Update

Reviews (13)

Write a Review

Ronnie Bignell

Aug 17, 2021

Report

If you want a cake with the WOW factor, then this is the place. Really helpful in helping me design the cake and size it and I was really pleased with what they made and could not recommend them enough.

Nathalie Edwards

Mar 16, 2021

Report

Thank you for an absolutely delicious and brilliantly decorated Hungry Caterpillar cake for our daughters 1st birthday!

Sandra Gray

Jan 16, 2021

Report

We all need some extra indulgence at the moment! Thank you so much butter and cream cakes, the cakes were delicious ❤

Robyn Louise Somerville

Aug 28, 2020

Report

Thankyou so much for my birthday cake! Coffee is my absolute fave. I love your cakes and usually go for the blueberry & lemon. This is equally as amazing 😍

Mary Reckert Geller

Feb 21, 2020

Report

Best brownies ever! I visited from the US and cant stop talking about the delicious brownies! Tried them at the market and want to keep going back! Staff is VERY friendly!
Edit: Brownies were delivered to the US, OMG they are the best! Thank you so much for sending them here! Frank and I are enjoying every bite!

Kirsty Wareham

Nov 24, 2019

Report

Fantastic birthday cake made for my husband. Professional service and excellent communication when ordering via email.

Rebekah Palmer

Apr 20, 2019

Report

I had a cake made for my parents wedding anniversary and it was delicious 😋 All the staff were a delight to deal with - thank you, I’ll be back!

Sarah Summers

Dec 31, 2018

Report

We absolutely LOVE Butter and Cream cakes! We always have our occasion cakes from here, and our treats! Today was a chocolate Bonkers cake for a birthday, last minute completely made the day.

Sinead Emma Hunter

Dec 16, 2018

Report

Created such a lovely cake for my daughter’s birthday, looked lovely and tasted so good, everyone at the party commented on how nice it was. Massive thank you to the team 🥰

David Parry

Dec 06, 2018

Report

Fantastic Cake! Asked for a personalised cake for my partners birthday. It was very reasonably priced, I was served by fantastically kind people, it tasted as amazing as it looked and best of all my partner loved it!! I would highly recommend this bakery

Lu Forrester

Dec 01, 2018

Report

Made an amazing cake for my boyfriend's 26th!!! Fast service, reliable was absolutely delicious! Staff friendly and helpful! It was really easy to order and collect, my boyfriend loved it I got one of the bonkers cakes will definitely be returning!

Charlotte Andrews

Sep 10, 2018

Report

Totally thrilled with our 'Half Bonkers' cake for 50 on Saturday. Looked magnificent ... and tasted superb too! Many, many thanks ... Charlotte Andrews

G. C.

Oct 21, 2017

Report

We always go to Butter and Cream for our birthday cakes and every time they are so brilliant. The carrot cake is incredible, and the ever changing brownies are also a treat! I urge everyone in the area to go to Butter and Cream!
Of course you can use the review!!!

Butter & Cream Cakes